Alright, I'm back. I'm sure nobody noticed my absence as this blog is more of a collection of my ramblings for easy reference, but after a getting married, moving states and getting a new career I'm backing to hacking away at OSR rules.
My recent obsession is Knave, I won't go into depth as you can find great reviews of this across the internet, but what really caught my eye was how simple and distilled it is, you've got your stats to determine your chance of success, and then your gear makes the character.
Now, I find this... Somewhat fails in reality, Knave makes it so Fighter types use all their inventory on weapons and armor, magic users on spells... And that's sorta where it starts to lose steam. Thief type characters can load up on 10 foot poles, bear traps, and Lock Picks, but a Fighter with a decent Constitution can also pick up a pair of Lock Picks and, in theory be just as good.
The bright side is that Knave is designed with modification and expanding in mind, which has been my downfall. I have gone from the 7 pages of light, tight, & original rules to... 44 pages, with UVG Overland Travel Rules, Vaults of Yaarn & UVG races, custom classes into the classless system, and a codified Dungeon Crawl Procedures.
Is this a bad thing? Not really, it's no longer as tight as I'd like, and I think I need to get better at really trimming the fat and formatting the document better, but no matter what, you're going to get bigger than 7 pages with Knave, you're going to want to add something, even if it's just some sort of rules for a Cleric type character.
I won't be sharing what I've created just yet, because it's currently rules from multiple sources (UVG, Vaults of Yaarn, Other Knave Hacks...), with little of my own actual creativity in it just yet, and because three weeks ago I was sure I was going to make a Other Dust & Ultra Violet Grassland mashup, and went through half the effort of making it.
I may have to sit down and figure out more specifically what I need out of my RPG game, or maybe I just need to run more games to figure out what works and doesn't work real time. Well, I'm currently on break while a buddy runs an Only War campaign for me and my friends (First time being a player in 7 years, heck of a feeling), so I got time to figure it out.
I also got a copy of Mythic Game Master Emulator on my desk I've never opened...